Jacksonville's pizza scene genuinely spans every major style, from New York-inspired hand-tossed pies to authentic Neapolitan wood-fired pizza, Detroit-style squares, and Chicago deep dish, reflecting the city's genuinely diverse culinary influences. This guide covers Jacksonville and its surrounding areas, including Riverside, Avondale, San Marco, Southside, Mandarin, Atlantic Beach, and Jacksonville Beach. In Jacksonville Magazine's Best in Jax 2026 awards, Al's Pizza won Best Pizza, with V Pizza named runner-up, while Tripadvisor currently ranks Moon River Pizza #1 among the city's pizzerias.
Al's Pizza — Jacksonville Magazine's official 2026 Best Pizza winner, founded in the city in 1988 — is the definitive first Jacksonville pizza recommendation. Moon River Pizza — Tripadvisor's current #1 Jacksonville pizzeria, known for its genuine New York-style thin crust — delivers one of the most beloved pizza experiences in the city. And V Pizza + Sidecar — an authentic Neapolitan specialist using Stefano Ferrara ovens imported from Naples — rounds out the trio of pizzerias every serious Jacksonville pizza itinerary should consider first.
This guide ranks the best pizzerias in Jacksonville, Florida — covering the city's most award-winning hand-tossed specialists, its most essential Neapolitan and New York-style pizzerias, and its most important historic and modern openings — with the honest context that helps you eat the best pizza Jacksonville has to offer. This guide ranks the 10 best pizzerias in Jacksonville.
Quick Comparison: Best Pizzerias in Jacksonville
| Pizzeria | Neighborhood | Style | Signature Pizza | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Al's Pizza | Riverside/citywide | Hand-Tossed, New York-Inspired | Spicy Caribbean Chicken | $15–25 |
| Moon River Pizza | Murray Hill/Edgewood | Thin Crust, New York-Style | The Special, White Pizza | $20–25 |
| V Pizza + Sidecar | San Marco | Authentic Neapolitan | Margherita Classico | $18–30 |
| Pie95 Pizza | Riverside/King Street | Wood-Fired | Romantica | $17–21 |
| Rodrigo's Craft Pizza | Riverside | Artisan, Neapolitan-Inspired | Nutty Mortadella | $16–22 |
| Carmine's Pie House | Riverside | New York and Chicago Deep Dish | Chicago Deep Dish | $15–30 |
| Electric Dough Pizza Co. | San Marco | Detroit-Style | The Godfather Part II | $15–25 |
| Joseph's Pizza | North Jacksonville | Traditional Italian-American | Joseph's Special | $15–29 |
| Pizza Point | Southside/Gate Parkway | American, Thin Crust | Meat Lovers | $10–30 |
| Biggie's Pizza | Riverside/Five Points | New York-Style, Late-Night | Classic Slice | $10–20 |
The 10 Best Pizzerias in Jacksonville: Full Reviews
1. Al's Pizza — The Best Pizzeria in Jacksonville
Location: 1620 Margaret St, Riverside, with additional locations citywide | Price: $15–25 per pizza | Best For: Jacksonville Magazine's official 2026 Best Pizza winner, a creative Caribbean-inspired specialty pie, fresh daily-made dough
Al's Pizza holds its position as Jacksonville's best pizzeria through its genuine local roots, founded in the city in 1988 by an Italian immigrant who arrived in the United States in 1978 and spent a decade honing his craft in New Jersey and New York's finest pizzerias before opening his own restaurant. The pizzeria refuses frozen dough, conveyor ovens, and canned vegetables, making fresh dough daily, often twice daily, and grating whole-milk mozzarella on-site with produce delivered six days a week.
The distinctive Spicy Caribbean Chicken, with creamy peppery sauce, island spices, and mozzarella, alongside the classic Margherita, made with Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and EVOO, demonstrate a menu whose creative, American approach distinguishes it from more traditional Italian pizzerias. Al's Pizza was named Best Pizza in Jacksonville Magazine's Best in Jax 2026 awards, with V Pizza finishing runner-up.
The honest verdict: The best pizzeria in Jacksonville — for guests who want the city's officially recognized best pizza with a genuinely creative signature pie, Al's Pizza is the non-negotiable first recommendation.
2. Moon River Pizza — The Best New York-Style Pizza in Jacksonville
Location: 1176 Edgewood Ave S, Murray Hill/Edgewood | Price: $20–25 per pizza | Best For: Tripadvisor's current #1 Jacksonville pizzeria, genuine thin-crust New York style, a relaxed neighborhood atmosphere
Moon River Pizza delivers the strongest New York-style pizza experience in Jacksonville, currently ranked #1 among the city's pizzerias on Tripadvisor with roughly 4.6 out of 5 across more than 300 platform reviews, and around 4.7 out of 5 across more than 3,600 reviews on its current business listing. The restaurant hand-stretches its dough without conveyor belts, topping it with genuine tomato sauce and freshly grated mozzarella.
The loaded Special, combining pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and black olives, alongside the classic Pepperoni and the herb-forward White Pizza, demonstrate a menu whose thin, crispy crust and generous toppings capture genuine New York pizzeria tradition. The relaxed, beer-and-friends atmosphere suits a casual night out.
The honest verdict: The best New York-style pizza in Jacksonville — for guests who want the city's most beloved thin-crust pizza in a genuinely relaxed setting, Moon River Pizza is the outstanding choice.
3. V Pizza + Sidecar — The Most Authentic Neapolitan Pizza in Jacksonville
Location: 1406 Hendricks Ave, San Marco | Price: $18–30 per pizza | Best For: Genuinely authentic Neapolitan pizza, ovens imported from Naples, San Marzano tomatoes and bufala mozzarella
V Pizza + Sidecar delivers the most authentic Neapolitan pizza experience in Jacksonville, the entire concept built specifically around bringing genuine Neapolitan pizza to the city. The restaurant's ovens, produced by Stefano Ferrara in Naples, reach roughly 900°F, cooking a pizza in around 90 seconds, a genuinely rare technical standard in the region.
The essential Margherita Classico, the definitive test of dough and sauce quality, alongside the spicy Diavola and pizzas featuring genuine bufala mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and Prosciutto di Parma, demonstrate a menu whose Italian ingredients are treated with real seriousness. V Pizza recommends eating with a knife and fork, just as in Naples, rather than folding a slice by hand.
The honest verdict: The most authentic Neapolitan pizza in Jacksonville — for guests who want a genuinely traditional Neapolitan experience, complete with imported Italian ovens and ingredients, V Pizza + Sidecar is the outstanding choice.
4. Pie95 Pizza — The Best Wood-Fired Pizza in Jacksonville
Location: 1510 King St, Riverside/King Street | Price: $17–21 per pizza | Best For: Genuinely artisanal wood-fired pizza, a strong reputation among serious local enthusiasts, creative topping combinations
Pie95 Pizza delivers the strongest wood-fired pizza experience in Jacksonville, its dedicated artisan approach having earned it a rating around 4.8 out of 5 and consistent recognition from the city's most serious pizza enthusiasts. The restaurant's entire identity centers on the wood-fired oven rather than any single regional style.
The classic Margherita, a genuine test of dough and sauce, the creative Romantica, topped with cherry tomato, arugula, balsamic glaze, and Parmesan, and the vegetarian-friendly Fungi, with locally farmed mushrooms, demonstrate a menu whose wood-fired technique rewards guests seeking genuine gastronomic ambition. Pie95's wood-fired wings, including Buffalo and Korean BBQ, add an unexpected bonus.
The honest verdict: The best wood-fired pizza in Jacksonville — for guests who want genuinely artisanal, gastronomic pizza, Pie95 Pizza is the outstanding choice.
5. Rodrigo's Craft Pizza — The Best New Artisan Pizzeria in Jacksonville
Location: 1029 Park St, Riverside | Price: $16–22 per pizza | Best For: A genuinely slow-fermented dough, creative gourmet toppings, a dedicated gluten-free line
Rodrigo's Craft Pizza delivers one of the most exciting recent additions to Jacksonville's pizza scene, its dough prepared with a biga starter and fermented for at least 72 hours, a genuinely serious technical commitment rarely matched by newer pizzerias. The restaurant's creative topping combinations distinguish it from the city's more traditional options.
The distinctive Nutty Mortadella, combining mortadella, ricotta, pistachio pesto, and pistachio bits, and the elegant Bella, with prosciutto, arugula, cherry tomatoes, and balsamic glaze, demonstrate a menu whose gourmet ambition sets it apart. A dedicated No-Gluten-Added line, prepared with separate dough and equipment, adds real inclusivity.
The honest verdict: The best new artisan pizzeria in Jacksonville — for guests who want genuinely slow-fermented, gourmet pizza, Rodrigo's Craft Pizza is the outstanding choice.
Explore Jacksonville Beyond Pizza
A Jacksonville pizza evening pairs naturally with the region's coastal attractions, easily combined with an Amelia Island salt marsh paddle tour earlier in the day before a casual dinner in Riverside or San Marco.
6. Carmine's Pie House — The Best New York and Chicago Deep Dish in Jacksonville
Location: 2677 Forbes St, Riverside | Price: $15–30 per pizza | Best For: Two genuinely distinct pizza styles under one roof, free parking, a strong local reputation
Carmine's Pie House delivers a genuinely unique proposition in Jacksonville, offering both classic thin, foldable New York-style pizza and substantial Chicago deep dish, baked in a deep pan with cheese, toppings, and sauce layered on top. Restaurantji currently ranks it first among Jacksonville pizzerias, with a rating around 4.7 out of 5.
The classic New York Thin Cheese Pie and the substantial Chicago Deep Dish, eaten with a knife and fork, demonstrate a menu whose dual identity offers genuine variety within a single restaurant. Free parking directly in front of the restaurant is a genuine convenience in the busy Riverside neighborhood.
The honest verdict: The best New York and Chicago deep dish in Jacksonville — for guests who want to compare two genuinely distinct American pizza styles in one visit, Carmine's Pie House is the outstanding choice.
7. Electric Dough Pizza Co. — The Most Original Pizza in Jacksonville
Location: 1996 San Marco Blvd, San Marco | Price: $15–25 per pizza | Best For: Genuine Detroit-style pizza, a distinctive former-theater setting, a strong late-night happy hour
Electric Dough Pizza Co. delivers the most genuinely original pizza experience in Jacksonville, opened in June 2025 inside the former San Marco Theatre, retaining elements of the old movie house rather than imitating classic Italian pizzeria design. The restaurant's Detroit-style approach, thicker, crispy-edged, and softer at the center, stands apart from the city's more numerous Neapolitan and New York specialists.
The signature Godfather Part II, loaded with Genoa salami, soppressata, coppa, pepperoni, sausage, Parmesan, and Calabrian chili crunch, demonstrates a menu whose maximalist approach rewards adventurous eaters. The Friday and Saturday Late Night Happy Hour, running 10pm to midnight with a Medium AMP Cheese Pizza for $10, adds real value for a late-night crowd.
The honest verdict: The most original pizza in Jacksonville — for guests who want genuinely modern, Detroit-style pizza in a distinctive former-theater setting, Electric Dough Pizza Co. is the outstanding choice.
8. Joseph's Pizza — The Most Historic Pizzeria in Jacksonville
Location: 7316 N Main St, North Jacksonville | Price: $15–29 per pizza | Best For: The city's oldest pizzeria, more than 70 years of family history, traditional Italian-American recipes
Joseph's Pizza delivers the most historically significant pizza experience in Jacksonville, its original North Main Street location having shared its dinner table with the city since 1956, making it the oldest pizzeria in Jacksonville. The restaurant remains genuinely family-run, with founder Joseph's wife, Mama Rose, daughters, and grandchildren continuing to run the business across both Jacksonville locations.
The loaded Joseph's Special, featuring pepperoni, Italian sausage, beef, ham, mushrooms, black olives, onions, green peppers, and anchovies, demonstrates a menu whose old-school, everything-included approach reflects genuine decades-old family tradition. The lively, loud-chatter-encouraged atmosphere adds real neighborhood character.
The honest verdict: The most historic pizzeria in Jacksonville — for guests who want more than 70 years of genuine family pizza tradition, Joseph's Pizza is the outstanding choice.
9. Pizza Point — The Best Value Pizza in Jacksonville
Location: 7860 Gate Pkwy, Southside/Gate Parkway | Price: $10–30 per pizza | Best For: Genuine variety, large portions for groups, accessible pricing
Pizza Point delivers the strongest value proposition among Jacksonville's pizzerias, its genuinely wide menu and large-format pizzas making it a favorite for families and groups wanting quantity without a premium price. The restaurant's menu extends well beyond pizza into calzones, stromboli, gyros, subs, pasta, and wings.
The classic Cheese, hearty Meat Lovers, and distinctive Goat Lovers and Hawaiian BBQ Chicken demonstrate a menu whose variety rewards groups with differing tastes. A 16-inch Cheese pizza runs around $18, while a 16-inch Meat Lovers runs around $31 on current delivery menus.
The honest verdict: The best value pizza in Jacksonville — for families and groups wanting genuine variety and large portions without overspending, Pizza Point is the outstanding choice.
10. Biggie's Pizza — The Best Late-Night Pizza in Jacksonville
Location: 1053 Park St, Riverside/Five Points | Price: $10–20 per pizza | Best For: The city's genuine reference point for late-night pizza, Five Points nightlife, a casual slice-and-drink format
Biggie's Pizza rounds out this list as Jacksonville's strongest late-night pizza destination, its Five Points location staying open until midnight on weekdays and 2am on Fridays and Saturdays, making it a genuine option after a night out. The restaurant serves large, generously topped New York-style pizza designed primarily to be eaten by the slice.
While the technical quality doesn't rival Moon River, Carmine's, or V Pizza, the restaurant's location and hours make it a genuinely useful stop for Five Points bar hopping and casual late-night dining. The straightforward, no-frills format suits guests wanting a quick, satisfying slice.
The honest verdict: The best late-night pizza in Jacksonville — for guests wrapping up a night out in Five Points, Biggie's Pizza is the outstanding choice.
How to Choose the Right Jacksonville Pizzeria
By Style
For genuinely authentic Neapolitan pizza, V Pizza + Sidecar's imported Naples ovens are unmatched anywhere in the city, delivering real Italian technical precision. For classic New York style, Moon River Pizza's Tripadvisor-topping thin crust delivers genuine East Coast credentials, backed by thousands of positive reviews. For a change of pace, Electric Dough's Detroit-style pies and Carmine's Chicago deep dish are both genuinely unmissable for guests seeking something different. For the best value, Pizza Point delivers real quantity and variety without premium pricing.
Best Areas for Pizza in Jacksonville
Riverside concentrates Al's Pizza, Pie95, Rodrigo's Craft Pizza, Carmine's Pie House, and Biggie's Pizza within a genuinely walkable pizza-rich district known citywide. San Marco is home to V Pizza + Sidecar and Electric Dough Pizza Co., both offering genuinely distinctive styles worth the trip. Murray Hill/Edgewood delivers Moon River Pizza and its Tripadvisor-topping reputation. North Jacksonville is home to Joseph's Pizza and more than 70 years of family history. Southside offers Pizza Point and its genuine value proposition.
Essential Pizzas to Try in Jacksonville
- Spicy Caribbean Chicken — Al's Pizza's genuinely distinctive signature creation
- Margherita Classico — the essential test of any Neapolitan pizzeria's dough, tomato, and mozzarella
- The Special — Moon River Pizza's loaded, genuinely satisfying New York-style classic
- Nutty Mortadella — Rodrigo's Craft Pizza's genuinely gourmet signature pie
- Chicago Deep Dish — a genuine change of pace at Carmine's Pie House
- The Godfather Part II — Electric Dough's maximalist Detroit-style creation
- Joseph's Special — a genuine everything-included classic with more than 70 years of history
- Romantica — Pie95's elegant, wood-fired gourmet pie
- Fungi — a genuinely earthy vegetarian option at Pie95
- White Pizza — a garlicky, cheese-forward classic found at Moon River and beyond
Price Guide
- Classic pizza: $10–20
- Gourmet pizza: $20–30
Insider Tips for Pizza in Jacksonville
A little planning helps you make the most of Jacksonville's busiest and most acclaimed pizzerias.
- Al's Pizza was officially named Best Pizza in Jacksonville Magazine's Best in Jax 2026 awards, with V Pizza finishing runner-up.
- If you want to compare pizza styles during your stay, try V Pizza for Neapolitan, Moon River for New York style, and Electric Dough or Carmine's for Detroit style and Chicago deep dish.
- Carmine's Pie House offers free parking directly in front, a genuine convenience in busy Riverside.
- Electric Dough's Late Night Happy Hour, Friday and Saturday from 10pm to midnight, offers a $10 Medium AMP Cheese Pizza.
- Biggie's Pizza is one of the few genuinely late-night options, staying open until 2am on Fridays and Saturdays.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizzeria in Jacksonville?
Al's Pizza was officially named Best Pizza in Jacksonville Magazine's Best in Jax 2026 awards, known for its creative Spicy Caribbean Chicken pizza and fresh daily-made dough.
What is Jacksonville's #1 pizzeria on Tripadvisor?
Moon River Pizza currently holds the #1 spot among Jacksonville pizzerias on Tripadvisor, known for its genuine New York-style thin crust.
Where can I find authentic Neapolitan pizza in Jacksonville?
V Pizza + Sidecar in San Marco is the city's genuine reference point for authentic Neapolitan pizza, using ovens imported from Naples.
What is the oldest pizzeria in Jacksonville?
Joseph's Pizza, open since 1956 on North Main Street, is the oldest pizzeria in Jacksonville and remains family-owned to this day.
Where can I find Detroit-style or Chicago deep dish pizza in Jacksonville?
Electric Dough Pizza Co. in San Marco specializes in Detroit-style pizza, while Carmine's Pie House in Riverside offers both New York thin crust and Chicago deep dish.
What is the best value pizza in Jacksonville?
Pizza Point in Southside offers the strongest value among Jacksonville's top-rated pizzerias, with large pizzas and genuine menu variety.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Jacksonville?
Biggie's Pizza in Five Points is the city's genuine reference point for late-night pizza, staying open until 2am on Fridays and Saturdays.
Is Jacksonville a good city for pizza?
Yes — with an officially recognized Best Pizza winner at Al's, a Tripadvisor-topping New York specialist at Moon River, and genuine Neapolitan authenticity at V Pizza, Jacksonville offers real variety across every major pizza style and price point.
Final Verdict
Jacksonville's pizza scene combines genuine local pride with authentic international technique, anchored by Al's Pizza's officially recognized Best Pizza status, Moon River's Tripadvisor-topping New York credentials, and V Pizza's imported Neapolitan ovens. The city's range extends from more than 70 years of family tradition at Joseph's Pizza to genuinely modern Detroit-style pies at Electric Dough, giving pizza lovers a complete education across every neighborhood and style. Whether the goal is a creative Spicy Caribbean Chicken pizza at Al's, a classic loaded slice at Moon River, or an authentic Margherita at V Pizza, this list of the ten best pizzerias in Jacksonville reflects a city whose pizza ambition spans every major American and Italian style.